Literature Review and Theoretical Framework

A literature review is a comprehensive, critical summary of previous research on a specific topic. It helps to understand the current state of knowledge, identify gaps, and position your own research in the context of existing studies. It’s a crucial part of academic work, especially in research projects, theses, and dissertations.

• Understand the current state of knowledge on a specific topic.
• Identify gaps in the existing literature or areas where further research is needed.
• Develop a theoretical framework or support a hypothesis for your own research.
• Provide a context for your research by grounding it in the existing body of work.
• Avoid duplication of past research by ensuring your work builds on previous studies.

Steps in Conducting a Literature Review

Define the research question or topic:

Clearly identify the subject or question you want to explore. This helps narrow down the scope of your review and ensures that you focus on relevant sources.

Search for relevant literature:

• Conduct a broad search to gather sources, such as books, peer-reviewed journal articles, conference papers, dissertations, and other credible materials.
• Search engines like Google Scholar, databases like JSTOR, PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science are common academic sources. Many universities offer access to subscription-based databases as well.

Obtain the literature:

• Once you have identified potential sources, gather them by accessing digital versions through databases, university subscriptions, or public repositories. You may also access physical copies from libraries.

Evaluate the quality of the literature

• Critically evaluate the credibility, relevance, and quality of the sources you find. Look for peer-reviewed articles, books by experts in the field, and high-impact journals.
• Assess the methodology used in research articles to ensure they are appropriate and robust.
• Take note of the publication date—make sure to focus on recent studies unless historical perspectives are necessary for your topic.

Analyze and synthesize the literature

• Organize the literature by themes, trends, methodologies, or findings, and identify patterns, contradictions, or gaps.
• Compare and contrast different studies, noting their strengths, weaknesses, and contributions to the field.

Write the review

• Present your findings clearly and concisely. Discuss the strengths and limitations of the studies you’ve reviewed and highlight the areas where further research is needed.
• Use a proper citation style (APA, MLA, Chicago, etc.) as per the requirements of your project.

Update and refine

• As new literature is continuously published, keep your review up-to-date by incorporating the latest studies relevant to your topic.

Literature Search Through the Internet

Keywords and Search Terms:

• Develop a list of specific keywords or phrases that relate directly to your topic. Use Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) to narrow or expand your search

Academic Databases:

• Use databases such as Google Scholar (for scholarly articles), PubMed (for health sciences), JSTOR (for humanities and social sciences), ERIC (for education), Scopus, and Web of Science for a more comprehensive collection of peer-reviewed sources.

Advanced Search Filters:

• Use filters to narrow your search by publication date, type of publication (e.g., peer-reviewed journals), or subject area.

Reading Abstracts:

• Read abstracts and summaries to determine whether an article is relevant before downloading or accessing the full text.

Accessing Full Text:

• If access is restricted, use academic libraries, interlibrary loan systems, or consider contacting the author directly. Many researchers share PDFs of their papers upon request.

Open Access Journals

• Search for open-access journals or repositories like arXiv, PubMed Central, or Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), which provide free access to full-text articles.

Reference Lists:

• After reviewing key articles, check their reference lists for other relevant works that may have been cited but missed in your search.

Formatting and Guidelines for Presenting the Literature Review

Title Page (if required)

• If you’re submitting a report or dissertation, include a title page that contains the title of your literature review, your name, the course, the instructor’s name, and the date.

Abstract (optional):

• A concise summary of the review, typically 150-250 words.
• Include the purpose of the literature review, the scope, and the key findings or conclusions.

Introduction

• Context and Importance: Introduce the topic you are reviewing, why it is significant, and the scope of your review (i.e., the time period, geographical focus, or research question).
• Purpose: Clearly state the purpose of the literature review (e.g., to synthesize existing research, identify gaps, inform your own research, etc.).
• Research Questions/Objective: If applicable, introduce your central research question or hypothesis.

Methodology (if required):

• Search Strategy: Describe the databases, keywords, and search criteria you used to gather the literature (e.g., peer-reviewed articles, books, or grey literature).
• Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria: Specify any criteria you applied to select or exclude sources (e.g., publication date, language, subject relevance).
• Review Method: If using systematic or scoping reviews, mention the method for synthesizing or categorizing literature.

Thematic or Theoretical Synthesis (Main Body)

This is the core of the literature review, where you summarize, analyze, and synthesize the literature.

Possible structures for this section:

• Thematic Structure: Organize your review by major themes or topics found in the literature.
  • Example: If reviewing literature on climate change, you might have sections on the science of climate change, its impacts on ecosystems, and human responses to it.
• Chronological Structure: Present studies in the order they were published to show the progression of research over time.
  • Example: Early studies focused on the theory of climate change, while later studies look into its economic consequences.
• Methodological Structure: Organize the review based on the methods used in the research (qualitative, quantitative, mixed-methods, etc.).
  • Example: One section could focus on qualitative research studies, another on quantitative studies, and so on.
• Theoretical Framework: If applicable, group literature by theories or conceptual frameworks used by the authors. For instance, if reviewing research on motivation, you could discuss literature through the lens of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs or Self-Determination Theory.
• Key Findings: For each theme or section, highlight the major findings, common points, contradictions, and the implications of the research.

Discussion and Conclusion

• Summary: Recap the key findings of the literature review.
• Research Gaps: Highlight areas where further research is needed or areas that have not been fully explored.
• Implications: Discuss the implications of the findings for your own research or for the broader field.
• Theoretical or Practical Contributions: If relevant, mention how the review contributes to theory or practice.

References/Bibliography

• List all the sources you cited in your review. Use the appropriate citation style (e.g., APA, MLA, Chicago) as required by your institution or publication.

Theoretical Framework – Concept and Format

Concept of a Theoretical Framework:

A theoretical framework provides a foundation for your research by drawing on theories, concepts, and existing knowledge to guide your study. It sets the context and helps to justify your research questions, methodology, and the interpretation of your findings.

Purpose

• Establishes a lens through which you analyze your research topic.
• Explains the relationships between variables or concepts in your research.
• Provides a solid base to develop hypotheses or predictions.

Content

• Key Concepts and Theories: Describe the theories and concepts relevant to your research topic. These could be established in prior studies or emerging theoretical perspectives.
• Variables or Constructs: Identify the variables or constructs that are central to your study, explaining their relationship based on theoretical perspectives.
• Hypotheses or Propositions: If your study is hypothesis-driven, present any theoretical predictions.

Format of a Theoretical Framework

Introduction: Briefly introduce the theoretical perspectives that are relevant to your research.

• Review of Key Theories: Discuss relevant theories in detail, explaining their foundational ideas and how they relate to your research topic.

• Research Questions or Hypotheses: Based on the theories discussed, outline your research questions or hypotheses.

• Application to Your Study: Explain how the theoretical framework applies to your research problem and how it guides your methodology and analysis.

• Visual Representation (optional): Sometimes, researchers include diagrams or models that depict the relationships between different concepts or variables.

Research and Theory – Deduction and Induction

Deductive Reasoning:

Deductive reasoning starts with a general theory or hypothesis and then tests it through specific observations or empirical data.

Process

• Begin with a theory or established knowledge.
• Develop hypotheses based on this theory.
• Test the hypotheses with data.
• Draw conclusions about the validity of the theory based on the results.

Inductive Reasoning

Inductive reasoning starts with observations or data and then moves toward developing a broader theory or generalization.

Process

• Begin with specific observations or data.
• Identify patterns or trends in the data.
• Develop a theory or general principle based on these observations.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the literature review provides a comprehensive synthesis of existing research, highlighting key findings, trends, and gaps in the field. It establishes the current state of knowledge, identifies areas for further exploration, and sets the stage for new contributions to the topic. The theoretical framework, in turn, grounds the study in established theories and concepts, offering a structured lens through which to analyze the research problem. By linking the literature review and theoretical framework, the study gains clarity on the direction of the research, how existing theories inform the study’s approach, and how the study will contribute to addressing identified gaps in the literature.

FAQ Questions

Related Content

• Introduction to Research